Associations Fight for Condo Fees
By Rachel Lee Coleman / Miami Herald
POMPONO
BEACH, Fla.
– In many condominium complexes, units sit
empty and association fees go uncollected when homeowners abandon their
property. In many cases, banks initiate foreclosure but postpone the final
order, effectively putting the condo in limbo because the bank doesn’t want to
become responsible for the unit’s obligations generally and homeowner
association fees specifically.
But some condos are trying a backdoor way of getting the banks to pay. Called a
“reverse foreclosure,” the associations foreclose on the unit first.
The problem starts with struggling homeowners who can no longer pay their
mortgage and who, in many cases, owe more on the mortgage than the unit is currently
worth. In most cases, a homeowner who stops paying his mortgage also stops
paying his association fees.
After months of no payments, banks may start the foreclosure process. However,
that can take a few months or a few years, depending on a number of factors,
many of which the bank controls. The unit, in financial limbo and usually
empty, is not yet a draw on the bank because it’s not on their books; but it’s
also not a revenue generator for the condo association.
To speed the process, condo associations are foreclosing first, which they may
legally do when maintenance fees remain unpaid for a period of time. Under this
reverse foreclosure, the association takes title to the unit; but since the
bank has a lien on the property, the association cannot legally sell it. The
association can, however, renounce its claim on the unit in court, effectively
giving ownership – and an obligation to pay maintenance fees – back to the
bank.
A reverse foreclosure is considered a hardball tactic, but condo associations
with a large number of foreclosures have little choice if they hope to maintain
common elements and keep the property safe. Without the power to make banks
pay, condo owners current on their mortgage and dues could be assessed large
special assessments to cover the unused units. Special assessments could then
cause even more owners to go into default, compounding the problem.
Even with a reverse foreclosure, a bank does not have to pay all past-due
maintenance fees. Florida
statutes limit the obligation to the past 12 months of association fees – six
months for condos – or 1 percent of the mortgage, which is less.
The cap is, in fact, a big reason why the banks aren’t in hurry. “There is no
incentive for banks to foreclose” in a timely fashion, says Ben Solomon, an
attorney with Association Law Group.
The Keys Gate Community Association in Miami-Dade survived a court challenge
when it used a reverse foreclosure to take a four-bedroom home. After the
foreclosure, the association found itself holding a vacant home it didn’t want
with $5,320 in unpaid fees it couldn’t collect. The home lender, HSBC Bank USA, had also
filed a foreclosure notice, but it had not done so not until two months later,
and it was in no hurry to take back the property.
A Miami-Dade circuit judge, Jerald Bagley, upheld the reverse foreclosure. On
Jan. 12, he ruled that the bank owed association fees, legal fees, court costs
and taxes. The bank still avoided $3,819 on the maintenance fees, however,
thanks to the cap in Florida
law.
The Keys Gate Community Association now has 13 more reverse foreclosures in the
pipeline.